Pin The Tail On The Bitch is the third episode in Season 1 of The Shadow Diaries.
As suspicious start surrounding Jenna, the girls try to prove that Jenna is C. But are they caught in a trap?
Summary: They try to prove that Jenna is C, only to find out that there's more than one. They realize that they were wrong in their predictions, and at the same time, Josh mysteriously disappears, but is found again by Sam in the woods. Josh has no memory of why he was there, only to make the gang suspicious of someone else.
- This is the first time Jenna appears.